6 Best Rubber Washers For Weatherproofing Metal Connections

A leaky metal roof is rarely the fault of the panels themselves; it is almost always the result of a failed fastener seal. When thermal expansion causes a metal roof to shift, the rubber washer bears the brunt of that movement while maintaining a watertight barrier. Choosing the right washer material and design is the difference between a roof that lasts fifty years and one that requires constant maintenance. These selections represent the industry standards for sealing metal-to-metal and metal-to-wood connections in various climates and project types.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Sealtite Kwikseal II: The Pro Roofer’s Top Choice

The Sealtite Kwikseal II is the go-to fastener for many professional roofing crews because it minimizes the margin for error during installation. Its design features a specialized head and washer configuration that helps prevent the washer from spinning or over-compressing.

When driving screws with an impact driver, the risk of “cupping” or blowing out the rubber is significant. This product is engineered to offer visual feedback, making it easier for installers to achieve the perfect seat every time.

For high-volume residential projects, speed and consistency are the primary metrics for success. This fastener excels in those environments, reducing the number of callbacks caused by improperly seated screws.

ST Fastening ZXL Washer: Best for Harsh Climates

Corrosion is the silent enemy of metal roof longevity, especially in regions with high humidity or salt air. The ZXL washer is designed to pair with fasteners that possess superior head coatings, ensuring the entire assembly resists rust for decades.

This washer’s design is wider than standard options, providing a larger footprint to bridge gaps or slightly off-center holes. It is the preferred choice for areas subject to extreme temperature swings, where the metal panel undergoes significant expansion and contraction.

If the project involves exposed fastener metal roofing in a coastal or industrial zone, this is the smart selection. It prevents the galvanic reaction that often occurs when moisture gets trapped under a low-quality washer.

Atlas Galv-Plus Bonded Washer: Top Value Bulk Buy

For large-scale agricultural or utility buildings where budget and volume are the primary concerns, the Atlas Galv-Plus bonded washer provides reliable performance. These are standard “bonded” washers, meaning the rubber is permanently adhered to the galvanized steel backing.

Bonded washers are highly predictable during installation. Because the rubber is locked to the metal collar, it resists the “walking” or shifting that can happen when using loose, unbonded rubber gaskets.

These are best utilized for pole barns, storage sheds, and secondary structures. While they lack the premium UV-resistance of high-end synthetic seals, they offer a proven, cost-effective solution for non-habitable spaces.

Levi’s 304 Stainless Washer: For Coastal Projects

When the job site is within a few miles of the ocean, standard galvanized components are not enough to survive the corrosive salt spray. Levi’s 304 stainless steel washers are essential in these environments to prevent the dreaded red-rust streaks on metal panels.

The 304-grade stainless provides an excellent balance of cost and corrosion resistance. It creates a neutral environment that won’t degrade, even when the fastener is exposed to harsh salt air for years on end.

Always pair these washers with stainless steel fasteners for the best results. Using a stainless washer on a cheaper, carbon-steel screw defeats the purpose by creating a sacrificial anode, leading to premature fastener failure.

Hillman Group Neoprene Washer: A Solid DIY Option

For the homeowner tackling a minor repair or a small shed project, accessibility is often just as important as technical performance. The Hillman Group neoprene washers are widely available at local hardware stores and provide a decent seal for light-duty applications.

These washers are effective for sealing leaks around existing fasteners or for secondary bracing work. They are not intended for heavy, high-wind roofing applications where extreme thermal movement is expected.

If the goal is to patch an existing hole or reinforce a loose connection on a non-structural panel, these serve the purpose well. However, avoid using them on a full roof replacement where a proprietary, integrated sealing system is required.

Buildex/ITW EPDM Sealer: The All-Around Workhorse

The Buildex/ITW EPDM sealer is the industry standard for high-performance roofing applications. EPDM (Ethylene Propylene Diene Monomer) is a synthetic rubber known for its incredible resistance to UV light, ozone, and extreme heat.

Unlike cheaper rubber compounds that become brittle and crack after a few seasons of sun exposure, EPDM remains flexible. It maintains a tight seal even after years of cycle-loading caused by wind uplift and thermal expansion.

This is the reliable “workhorse” for any professional contractor. It works well on almost any metal profile, providing the consistency and longevity required for a building that needs to stay dry for 30+ years.

EPDM vs. Neoprene: Choosing the Right Gasket Material

Understanding the difference between gasket materials is vital for long-term success. Neoprene is a versatile, mid-range rubber that performs well in moderate conditions but eventually degrades under persistent UV exposure.

EPDM is the superior material for roofing applications due to its high chemical and thermal stability. It resists ozone and weathering far better than neoprene, making it the only choice for exposed roofs in high-heat climates.

• Neoprene: Good for short-term fixes, interior applications, or low-cost projects.
• EPDM: The required standard for long-term roofing, high-sun exposure, and extreme weather zones.
• Hardness: Always look for a medium-durometer rubber to ensure it compresses without splitting.

How to Properly Torque a Sealing Screw and Washer

Over-tightening is the most common cause of roof leaks. If the rubber washer is compressed to the point where it flares out significantly, the seal is likely compromised.

The goal is to see a small, even “bead” of rubber emerging from beneath the metal backing of the washer. This indicates a perfect seal without causing the rubber to tear or fail prematurely.

Use an impact driver with an adjustable clutch if possible, or stop immediately once the washer contacts the metal surface. Proper torque ensures the washer lasts the full life of the fastener without cracking or losing its tension.

Matching Washer Size to Your Screw and Metal Panel

A washer that is too small will not provide enough surface area to cover the hole, leading to leaks. A washer that is too large may interfere with the ribs of a metal panel or prevent the screw from seating flat.

Standard roofing screws usually come with 1/2-inch to 5/8-inch diameter washers. For oversized holes or applications where the panel has been drilled incorrectly, oversized EPDM washers can bridge gaps up to 3/4-inch.

Always match the washer diameter to the screw shank and the specific rib profile of the metal. If the fastener is going into a high rib, ensure the washer has enough flexibility to contour to the slope of the ridge.

Signs of a Failing Washer and How to Replace Them

The first sign of a failing washer is often a small, persistent drip during heavy rain, or visible cracks in the rubber. If the rubber looks “melted,” dry, or is missing entirely, it is time for a full replacement.

Do not attempt to apply silicone or caulk over a failed washer; this is a temporary fix that will inevitably fail again. Instead, remove the old screw and replace it with a slightly larger, specialized “oversized-shank” roofing screw with a fresh EPDM washer.

Ensure the new screw bites into solid wood or metal. If the hole is stripped, a larger diameter screw or a toggle-style fastener may be required to regain structural integrity and restore the seal.

The longevity of a metal roof is inextricably linked to the quality of the seals at every penetration. Whether selecting premium EPDM washers for a new installation or replacing brittle gaskets on an aging system, prioritizing material quality and proper torque is non-negotiable. Invest in the right components today to avoid expensive water damage and constant maintenance throughout the life of the roof.